The best puppy training supplies make everyday lessons easier, whether you are rewarding a recall or building a potty routine. My best overall pick is Pupford Soft & Chewy Chicken Training Treats for their training-friendly format, while KISENG Extra Large Pee Pads suit households that need broad indoor coverage and Dog Training Clickers offer a simple way to mark behavior consistently. The main tradeoffs are convenience versus cleanup, disposable versus reusable potty options, and soft rewards versus longer-lasting chews. The right mix depends on your puppy’s size, appetite, schedule, and access to outdoor space. Read on for the full breakdown and guidance on choosing supplies that fit your routine.
Get pet supplies delivered free — and shop member deals
- Fast, free delivery on millions of items
- Access to Prime Big Deal Days deals on October 6–7
- Prime Video, Amazon Music and more included
Complete the kit
Key Takeaways
- Training treats serve different jobs: Pupford’s soft chicken treats suit frequent reward sessions, while freeze-dried beef liver offers a distinct, concentrated treat option and Wellness or Blue Buffalo provide alternatives for puppies with different preferences.
- Potty products split between convenience and reuse: KISENG and Earth Rated disposable pads simplify cleanup, while Caldwell’s washable pads and the Hompet grass tray can reduce reliance on single-use pads if you can manage regular washing.
- Indoor potty setups are not interchangeable: BrilliantPad adds automated waste handling, whereas the Hompet grass pad gives a larger turf-style surface without smart features.
- Communication tools work best as part of a routine: Doorbells from KEXIAVA or Luckyiren can support signaling, but puppies still need scheduled potty breaks and prompt rewards.
- Not every supply teaches a cue directly: A clicker helps mark the exact behavior, while the Snuggle Puppy and N-Bone teething sticks address settling and chewing needs that can affect training sessions.
| puppy training supplie | Brand |
|---|---|
| Wellness Soft Puppy Bites Lamb | — |
| Blue Buffalo Baby BLUE Savory | Blue Buffalo |
| Pupford Soft & Chewy Beef Trai | Pupford |
| Earth Rated XL Dog & Puppy Pee | — |
| BrilliantPad Smart Self-Cleani | — |
| Hompet Large Dog Grass Pad wit | Hompet |
| KEXIAVA Dog Doorbell Training | KEXIAVA |
| Pupford Soft & Chewy Training | — |
| Pupford Freeze-Dried Beef Live | Pupford |
| Luckyiren Upgraded Puppy Bells | — |
| Caldwell’s Pet Supply Co. Reus | Caldwell’s Pet Supply Co. |
| Snuggle Puppy Heartbeat Dog To | Snuggle Puppy |
| N-Bone Puppy Teething Sticks | N-Bone |
| KISENG Extra Large Dog Pee Pad | KISENG |
| Dog Training Clickers with Spr | HoAoOo |
More Details on Our Top Picks
Wellness Soft Puppy Bites Lamb and Salmon Dog Training Treats, Grain Free, 3 oz
For buyers who want a treat made specifically for young dogs, Wellness Soft Puppy Bites pair lamb and salmon with added vitamins and DHA. Their soft, bite-sized texture makes quick rewards practical during short training sessions, while blueberries and sweet potatoes add variety to the ingredient list. Compared with Pupford Soft & Chewy Beef Training Treats, this option is more clearly puppy-focused, but it does not provide the same stated calorie-per-treat figure or all-life-stages flexibility. The tradeoff is the 3 oz package and puppy-only positioning: frequent practice may use the bag quickly, and it is not the most adaptable choice for a household training both puppies and adult dogs. It also may not suit buyers seeking a single-protein recipe.
Pros:- Soft, bite-sized pieces suit frequent training rewards.
- Lamb and salmon provide two meat ingredients.
- Includes DHA and added vitamins.
- No meat byproducts, artificial colors, or artificial flavors.
Cons:- The 3 oz package may run out quickly during regular training.
- Formulated specifically for puppies rather than all life stages.
- The supplied details do not state calories per treat.
Best for: Puppy owners seeking soft, small rewards with DHA and ingredients including lamb and salmon.
Not ideal for: Households that want one treat for puppies and adult dogs, or buyers who need a stated low calorie count per piece.
- Product type:Soft puppy training treats
- Flavor:Lamb and salmon
- Dietary feature:Grain free
- Package size:3 oz
- Key ingredients:Lamb, salmon, blueberries, and sweet potatoes
- Added nutrients:Vitamins and DHA
Our verdict“Choose Wellness Soft Puppy Bites for puppy-focused, soft rewards with DHA, but pick Pupford if you need an all-life-stages treat with a stated low calorie count.”
Blue Buffalo Baby BLUE Savory Chicken Puppy Training Treats, 4 oz
Blue Buffalo Baby BLUE is a straightforward puppy-training pick for owners who want chicken named as the first ingredient and a tender piece that is easy to reward quickly. Its semi-moist, bite-sized format suits repeated practice, while DHA supports its puppy-oriented positioning. Compared with Wellness Soft Puppy Bites, this recipe centers on chicken rather than lamb and salmon, and it specifically excludes corn, wheat, and soy. That makes the ingredient profile easier to match to some household preferences, though it does not offer the same grain-free claim. The main compromise is the 4 oz bag, which can mean frequent restocking for active training; like Wellness, it is intended for puppies, not a shared puppy-and-adult treat supply. Buyers looking for a larger training pouch should compare it with Pupford’s 5 oz option.
Pros:- Real chicken is the first ingredient.
- Tender, bite-sized pieces are suited to training.
- Contains DHA for puppy cognitive development.
- Free from corn, wheat, soy, and artificial preservatives.
Cons:- The 4 oz bag may require frequent replacement with regular use.
- Puppy-specific formulation is less versatile than Pupford’s all-life-stages treats.
- Not described as grain free.
Best for: Puppy owners who prefer chicken-first, tender training treats without corn, wheat, or soy.
Not ideal for: Owners training puppies and adult dogs with the same treat, or those seeking a larger bag for frequent sessions.
- Brand:Blue Buffalo
- Flavor:Savory chicken
- Age range:Puppy
- Item form:Semi-moist
- Weight:4 oz
- Allergen information:Corn-free, soy-free, and wheat-free
- Key ingredients:Real chicken and DHA
- Manufacturer:Blue Buffalo Company, Ltd
Our verdict“Pick Baby BLUE for tender, chicken-first puppy rewards with specified ingredient exclusions, but choose Pupford for a larger bag and use across life stages.”
Pupford Soft & Chewy Beef Training Treats for Dogs and Puppies, 5 oz
When practice calls for many small rewards, Pupford Soft & Chewy Beef has a useful advantage: each treat contains less than 2 calories, and the bag is listed at 250-plus pieces. That combination makes it a more practical choice for repeated reinforcement than the smaller puppy-focused bags from Wellness or Blue Buffalo Baby BLUE. The soft texture also suits puppies and dogs with sensitive teeth, while the limited-ingredient positioning and USA production may appeal to owners who prefer a simpler recipe. Its broader all-life-stages use is another point of difference. The tradeoff is beef as the main flavor, which rules it out for dogs with beef sensitivities; buyers seeking puppy-specific DHA or a poultry recipe should look at the other treats instead.
Pros:- Less than 2 calories per treat supports frequent rewarding.
- 250-plus bite-sized pieces are listed per bag.
- Soft texture may suit dogs with sensitive teeth.
- Limited-ingredient recipe made in the USA for all life stages.
Cons:- Beef may not suit dogs with beef sensitivities.
- Does not list DHA or puppy-specific added nutrients.
- A single beef flavor offers less variety for dogs that prefer other proteins.
Best for: Owners training puppies or adult dogs with frequent small rewards, especially when calorie count and soft texture matter.
Not ideal for: Dogs with beef sensitivities, or puppy owners specifically seeking a treat with DHA.
- Brand:Pupford
- Flavor:Beef
- Weight:5 oz
- Treat count:250+ per bag
- Calories per treat:Less than 2 kcal
- Life stage:All life stages
- Special ingredients:Beef and sweet potato
- Diet type:Limited ingredient
- Made in:USA
Our verdict“Choose Pupford Beef for repeated, low-calorie rewards across life stages, but select Wellness or Baby BLUE if puppy-specific nutrients are your priority.”
Earth Rated XL Dog & Puppy Pee Pads, Discreet Top, Max Absorbency, 40CT
For indoor potty practice, the Earth Rated XL pads focus on fast absorption and leak control rather than smart features. The maker states that AbsorbShield+ absorbs liquid twice as fast and holds twice as much moisture as its comparison baseline; adhesive tabs and layered construction are intended to keep the pad in place and limit leaks. A built-in attractant may help direct a puppy to the pad, while the unscented, discreet green surface avoids a prominent printed appearance. Compared with the BrilliantPad Smart Self-Cleaning Indoor Dog Potty, Earth Rated is simpler and does not require Wi-Fi or a mechanism, but it still needs manual pad changes and disposal. The 28-inch square format offers room, though successful containment depends on the dog aiming near the center, and its thin profile adds little cushioning.
Pros:- Manufacturer states twice-faster absorption and twice the moisture capacity.
- Layered design and adhesive tabs are intended to reduce leaks and shifting.
- Unscented pad includes a built-in potty-training attractant.
- Discreet green surface helps obscure visible mess.
Cons:- The attractant may not draw every dog to the pad.
- Misses near the edges can still result in floor mess.
- Thin 0.04-inch profile provides little cushioning.
Best for: Puppy owners who want a large disposable pad with stated fast absorption, adhesive tabs, and an attractant.
Not ideal for: Owners seeking an automated, self-cleaning system or dogs that regularly miss the pad’s center.
- Product type:Extra-large disposable dog and puppy pee pads
- Dimensions:28 x 28 x 0.04 inches
- Pack count:40
- Item weight:8.29 pounds
- Absorption technology:AbsorbShield+
- Leak-control features:Layered design and adhesive tabs
- Odor and training features:Unscented with built-in attractant
- Manufacturer:Earth Rated
Our verdict“Choose Earth Rated for a large, high-absorbency disposable pad with no automated setup, but consider BrilliantPad if automatic pad advancement and waste sealing matter more.”
BrilliantPad Smart Self-Cleaning Indoor Dog Potty with Smartphone App and 1 Roll
BrilliantPad is the most automated potty option in this group: it advances a fresh pad after use, then wraps and seals the soiled one to help contain mess and odor. The included roll is described as equivalent to 21 traditional puppy pads, and Wi-Fi app access adds health insights alongside the system’s camera. Compared with the manually changed Earth Rated XL Pee Pads, this setup may reduce direct handling of used pads, but it brings a larger, heavier piece of equipment and more setup complexity. Its under-25-pound limit sharply narrows the audience, and it is intended for dogs already accustomed to using pads. The one included roll also means owners should account for replacement supplies. This is a specialized indoor solution, not a broad fit for every puppy or household.
Pros:- Automatically advances a fresh pad after use.
- Wraps and seals used pads to help limit mess and odors.
- App connectivity includes health insights, with a camera listed.
- Included roll is equivalent to 21 traditional puppy pads.
Cons:- Designed for dogs under 25 pounds, excluding larger puppies and dogs.
- Not intended for dogs that do not already use pads.
- At 34 x 24 x 6 inches and 10 pounds, it takes more space than loose pads.
- Only one pad roll is included.
Best for: Owners of small, pad-trained dogs under 25 pounds who want automated pad changes and app-connected monitoring.
Not ideal for: Owners of large dogs, dogs that do not use pads, or households wanting a low-footprint disposable-pad setup.
- Suitable dog size:Under 25 pounds
- Dimensions:34 x 24 x 6 inches
- Weight:10 pounds
- Included:One puppy pad roll
- Pad roll equivalent:21 traditional puppy pads
- Connectivity:Wi-Fi and smartphone app
- Cleaning features:Automatic pad advancement, waste wrapping, and sealing
- Other listed feature:Camera
Our verdict“Choose BrilliantPad for a small, pad-trained dog when automated cleanup is worth the equipment footprint, but use Earth Rated pads for a simpler manual routine.”
Hompet Large Dog Grass Pad with Tray, 41 x 27 Inches, Reusable Turf and Washable Pee Pads
The Hompet combines artificial turf, a drainage insert, a collection tray, and two washable pads, making it a more contained option than standalone reusable pads such as Caldwell’s Pet Supply Co. Reusable Washable Dog Pee Pads. Its large 41 x 27-inch footprint gives puppies room to use the surface, while the tray catches runoff that could otherwise reach the floor. Because it works indoors and outdoors and arrives with no assembly required, it can suit homes that need a ready-to-place potty station. The tradeoff is upkeep: turf, pads, and tray all need regular cleaning, so it is less hands-off than disposable pee pads such as Earth Rated XL Dog & Puppy Pee Pads. Choose it for a reusable setup, not for minimal cleaning.
Pros:- Three-layer design channels liquid toward the collection tray.
- Includes two washable pee pads and two replacement turf pieces.
- Can be used indoors or outdoors.
- Requires no assembly.
Cons:- Turf, pads, and tray all require regular cleaning.
- Its large footprint may not fit small rooms or narrow balconies.
Best for: Puppy owners in apartments or homes without easy outdoor access who want a reusable potty station with a catch tray.
Not ideal for: Owners seeking a low-cleanup solution or lacking space for a 41 x 27-inch potty surface.
- Brand:Hompet
- Size:41 x 27 inches
- Item dimensions:40.75 x 25.98 x 1.18 inches
- Item weight:4.76 kg
- Included replacement turf:2 pieces
- Material:Plastic
- Use:Indoor and outdoor
- Assembly:None required
Our verdict“Choose the Hompet if you want a roomy reusable potty station and are willing to clean its multiple layers regularly.”
KEXIAVA Dog Doorbell Training Bells, 2 Pack, Pink
The KEXIAVA set gives puppy owners two adjustable doorbells, a useful distinction from the single strap offered by the Luckyiren Upgraded Puppy Bells. Having a second bell can help when you use more than one exit or want a spare, while the 33–35-inch adjustable length accommodates different handles. The stainless steel bells are designed to make a clear sound, giving a puppy an audible way to ask for an outdoor break instead of relying on you to spot pacing or whining. The bells do not teach the signal by themselves: repeated practice and rewards are needed, just as with Luckyiren. The product text also gives inconsistent information about bell count, so buyers should verify what arrives if the exact number of bells matters.
Pros:- Two-pack can cover more than one door or provide a spare.
- Adjustable 33–35-inch length fits a range of handles.
- Stainless steel bells are designed to produce a clear sound.
- Can be taught as a paw- or nose-operated potty signal.
Cons:- Puppies need repeated practice and rewards to learn the cue.
- Product text is inconsistent about the bell count.
Best for: Puppy owners who want adjustable bells for multiple doors or a spare training strap.
Not ideal for: Buyers who need a clearly specified bell count or expect a puppy to learn the signal without consistent practice.
- Brand:KEXIAVA
- Quantity:2 pack
- Color:Pink
- Adjustable length:33–35 in
- Bell material:Stainless steel
- Bell size:1.4 in
- Item weight:5.9 oz
- Model number:00
Our verdict“Pick KEXIAVA if you want adjustable doorbells for more than one exit and can confirm the included bell count.”
Pupford Soft & Chewy Training Treats for Dogs & Puppies (Chicken, 5 oz)
For training that calls for quick, repeated rewards, these soft, one-bite chicken treats are the easier fit than the firmer, lightweight Pupford Freeze-Dried Beef Liver Training Treats. Each treat has less than 2 kcal, which can help owners reward often without adding as many calories as larger snacks. The chewy texture is also described as gentle on sensitive teeth, making this option suitable for puppies and older dogs alike. The main limitation is choice: this listing provides only chicken, so it may not work for dogs that dislike chicken or need another protein. Compared with the beef-liver option, it favors soft texture and a stated per-treat calorie figure over a freeze-dried, three-ingredient format.
Pros:- Less than 2 kcal per treat supports frequent rewarding.
- One-bite size helps keep rewards quick and portions small.
- Soft, chewy texture is gentle on sensitive teeth.
- Made in the USA.
Cons:- Chicken is the only listed flavor.
- The provided product details do not specify an ingredient list or treat count.
Best for: Puppy owners who reward frequently during short training sessions and prefer soft, small chicken bites.
Not ideal for: Dogs that avoid chicken or owners who want a freeze-dried treat with a stated limited ingredient count.
- Weight:5 oz
- Flavor:Chicken
- Calories per treat:Less than 2 kcal
- Protein:High
- Made in:USA
- Texture:Soft and chewy
Our verdict“Choose these chicken bites for frequent, soft rewards, but opt for another treat if your puppy needs a different protein.”
Pupford Freeze-Dried Beef Liver Training Treats for Dogs and Puppies, 4 oz
These beef-liver treats suit owners who want lightweight, bite-sized rewards they can carry on walks or keep handy for short practice sessions. The listing describes three simple ingredients and more than 475 treats per bag, giving handlers many small rewards without carrying bulky snacks. Compared with Pupford Soft & Chewy Chicken Training Treats, this freeze-dried option is the more travel-friendly choice; the chicken treats, by contrast, offer a soft texture and a specific under-2-kcal figure per bite. Beef flavor is the key constraint here, particularly for dogs with beef sensitivities or those that are not motivated by liver. Choose this option for portability and a short ingredient list, rather than for a soft chew or a clearly stated calorie count per treat.
Pros:- Bite-sized pellets suit quick training rewards.
- Lightweight and described as mess-free for carrying.
- Made with three ingredients.
- Listed for all life stages and breed sizes.
Cons:- Beef flavor may not suit dogs with beef sensitivities.
- No per-treat calorie figure is provided in the supplied details.
- Freeze-dried pellets may not suit dogs that need soft rewards.
Best for: Puppy owners who want compact, low-mess rewards for walks, outings, and brief training sessions.
Not ideal for: Dogs with beef sensitivities or owners who need a soft treat or specified calories per bite.
- Brand:Pupford
- Flavor:Beef liver
- Weight:4 oz
- Ingredients:3
- Treat count:475+ per bag
- Form:Pellet
- Life stage:All life stages
- Diet type:Limited ingredient
Our verdict“Choose these pellets for portable, limited-ingredient training rewards if your dog tolerates beef and does not need a soft texture.”
Luckyiren Upgraded Puppy Bells Dog Doorbells for Door Knob Potty Training – Premium Quality, Adjustable Length (3 Snaps)
Luckyiren is the more tailored pick for a single door: its nylon strap adjusts to three lengths with snap buttons, while the KEXIAVA set offers two adjustable bells with a listed length range. That snap-based setup lets owners choose a hanging position for their door and puppy, and the clear jingle gives the dog an audible way to request an outdoor trip. Its single-bell format is straightforward if you only need to train at one exit, but it offers less coverage than KEXIAVA’s two-pack. Neither option works without teaching: the puppy needs repeated practice to connect ringing with going outside. The provided details list an iron bell with a stainless steel core, so buyers seeking a fully stainless-steel bell should check that material distinction.
Pros:- Three snap positions adjust the strap length.
- Clear jingle provides an audible potty signal.
- Nylon strap attaches to a doorknob or handle.
- Includes a two-year manufacturer warranty.
Cons:- A single strap does not cover multiple exits like the KEXIAVA two-pack.
- Consistent owner-led practice is needed for the puppy to learn the cue.
- Bell is listed as iron with a stainless steel core, not entirely stainless steel.
Best for: Owners training a puppy to signal at one main door who want three strap-length settings.
Not ideal for: Households needing bells at multiple exits or buyers who require a bell made entirely of stainless steel.
- Pack size:Pack of 1
- Item weight:3.84 ounces
- Item dimensions:32 x 2.8 x 2.8 inches
- Color:Black
- Material:Nylon strap, iron bell with stainless steel core
- Adjustment:Three snap positions
- Warranty:2-year manufacturer warranty
- Age range:Puppy
Our verdict“Choose Luckyiren for one frequently used door when three snap-adjustable lengths matter more than having a second bell.”
Caldwell’s Pet Supply Co. Reusable Washable Dog Pee Pads (30×36, Set of 2)
For puppy owners who want to cut down on disposable pads, Caldwell’s two-pack offers a washable surface with a waterproof TPU backing and five-layer construction. Its 30-by-36-inch footprint suits medium dogs and can cover a crate area or a favorite indoor potty spot. Compared with KISENG’s 40-count disposable pads, this set creates less recurring waste, but you’ll need to wash and dry it between uses rather than simply replacing a soiled pad. The two-pad quantity helps keep a clean one ready while the other is in the laundry. Care is more specific than with disposables: cold water, low tumble drying, and no bleach or fabric softener. I’d choose it for repeat indoor training, but not for buyers who need a fresh pad without laundry.
Pros:- Five-layer construction is designed for absorbency during indoor potty training.
- Waterproof TPU backing helps protect floors beneath the pad.
- Two pads allow one to be in use while the other is being washed.
- Reusable design offers an alternative to repeatedly buying disposable pads.
Cons:- Requires careful washing and drying; bleach and fabric softener are not recommended.
- A 30-by-36-inch surface may not provide enough coverage for larger dogs or broad areas.
- Needs laundering after use, unlike KISENG disposable pads, which can be discarded.
Best for: Puppy owners training a medium-sized dog indoors who have laundry access and want a reusable alternative to disposable pads.
Not ideal for: People with very small crate areas, dogs needing coverage beyond 30 by 36 inches, or households that cannot wash pads regularly.
- Brand:Caldwell’s Pet Supply Co.
- Dimensions:30 × 36 inches
- Quantity:2 pads
- Construction:Five layers
- Backing:Thermoplastic polyurethane (TPU)
- Care:Machine or hand wash cold; tumble dry low; no bleach or fabric softener
- Warranty:1 year against manufacturer defects
Our verdict“Choose this washable two-pack if you want reusable coverage for a medium puppy and can keep up with its care instructions.”
Snuggle Puppy Heartbeat Dog Toy – Brown & White Beagle
Snuggle Puppy’s removable heartbeat device gives this plush toy a specific role: offering a familiar-feeling companion during crate practice, travel, or other unsettling moments. A disposable heat pack is included, adding warmth alongside the pulsing heartbeat. That makes it a different kind of training aid from HoAoOo’s two-pack clickers, which help mark behaviors rather than settle a puppy. The washable polyester exterior is practical for a toy that may travel between crate and car, but the internal components must come out before washing. Heat packs also need replacing, so this option involves more upkeep than a basic plush toy. I’d favor it for puppies who need help settling, while owners focused on teaching cues or rewarding behavior should put treats or a clicker first.
Pros:- Removable heartbeat device is designed to mimic a littermate’s presence.
- Included heat pack adds warmth for settling routines.
- Washable polyester exterior can be cleaned once internal parts are removed.
- Suitable for dogs of all breed sizes and life stages, according to the product data.
Cons:- Disposable heat packs require replacement.
- Heartbeat device and heat pack must be removed before washing.
- No warranty is listed.
Best for: New puppy owners working on crate training or travel routines with a dog that benefits from a soothing companion.
Not ideal for: Buyers seeking a direct training tool for teaching cues, or those who want a simple washable plush with no replaceable components.
- Brand:Snuggle Puppy
- Model:SP104
- Material:Polyester
- Dimensions:12 × 6.5 × 5 inches
- Weight:16 ounces
- Included components:Heartbeat device and heat pack
- Color:Brown and white
- Water resistance:Water resistant
Our verdict“Pick this toy when settling and crate comfort are the puppy-training challenges you need to address, rather than cue teaching.”
N-Bone Puppy Teething Sticks, Peanut Butter Flavor, 3.74 oz
When teething makes it harder for a puppy to focus, N-Bone’s pliable rice-based sticks offer an edible chew intended to soothe sore gums. The listed formula is rawhide-free and free of corn, wheat, and soy, with calcium and DHA added; each treat is listed at 14 calories. Unlike the soft training treats from Wellness Soft Puppy Bites, these sticks are aimed more at chewing relief than at delivering frequent, small rewards for repeated cues. That makes them a better fit for a chew break than for rapid-fire training sessions. There is also a product-detail mismatch: the title and listed flavor say peanut butter, while the item description says chicken. I’d confirm the flavor on the package before buying, especially for a puppy with food sensitivities.
Pros:- Pliable stick form is designed for puppies’ teething needs.
- Rice-based and rawhide-free.
- Listed as free of corn, wheat, and soy.
- Includes calcium and DHA and is listed at 14 calories per treat.
Cons:- Flavor information conflicts: peanut butter appears in the title and details, while the description says chicken.
- Puppy-specific formulation may not suit buyers shopping for an adult dog.
- Chew sticks are less suited to frequent, quick rewards than small training bites.
Best for: Puppy owners looking for a rawhide-free edible chew to occupy a teething puppy between short training sessions.
Not ideal for: Owners seeking tiny, quick-reward training treats, adult-dog chews, or a clearly consistent flavor listing.
- Brand:N-Bone
- Listed flavor:Peanut butter; item description also mentions chicken
- Life stage:Puppy
- Form:Stick
- Package weight:3.74 oz
- Calories:14 per treat
- Dietary features:Corn-free, wheat-free, soy-free, and rawhide-free
- Additional nutrients:Calcium and DHA omega-3
- Made in:USA
Our verdict“Choose these sticks as a puppy teething chew if the flavor is confirmed and you need chewing relief more than a rapid training reward.”
KISENG Extra Large Dog Pee Pads – 40 Count, 34″ x 28″, Leak-Proof & Super Absorbent
For potty training that calls for frequent pad changes, KISENG’s 40-count pack prioritizes disposable convenience and a larger landing area. Each pad measures 34 by 28 inches and has a six-layer core described as turning liquid into gel, with a reinforced PE backing intended to help protect floors. Compared with Caldwell’s reusable two-pad set, KISENG avoids laundry and supplies multiple replacements, but it creates ongoing waste and needs restocking. The dimensions may help puppies who miss a smaller target or households covering a larger indoor spot; they can also crowd a compact crate or tight room. I’d rank it ahead of reusable pads for buyers who value quick changes and plentiful coverage, not for those whose priority is reducing disposables.
Pros:- 40 pads provide multiple replacements for ongoing indoor training.
- 34-by-28-inch size gives broader coverage than a small training pad.
- Six-layer core is described as quickly turning liquid into gel.
- Reinforced PE backing is intended to help prevent leaks onto floors and furniture.
Cons:- Large dimensions may not fit small crates or confined spaces.
- Disposable format creates repeat waste and requires replenishment.
- The pack is less suitable for buyers seeking a reusable option like Caldwell’s washable pads.
Best for: Households potty-training a puppy in a larger indoor area and wanting multiple disposable pads for frequent changes.
Not ideal for: Owners with compact crates or limited floor space, or buyers who prefer washable pads to reduce disposable waste.
- Brand:KISENG
- Model:DTP-40PCS
- Dimensions:34 × 28 inches
- Count:40 pads
- Layers:6
- Material:Polyethylene (PE)
- Color:Blue
Our verdict“Choose KISENG for broad, replaceable indoor coverage when convenience matters more than reusability or compact sizing.”
Dog Training Clickers with Spring Wrist Straps and Keyrings, 2-Pack
HoAoOo’s two-clicker set is the most direct behavior-training tool in this group: a click marks the moment a puppy does the desired action, giving you a consistent cue before a reward. The pack includes black and blue clickers, so two household trainers can keep one each or use separate colors for different routines. Compared with N-Bone’s teething sticks, this is for teaching and reinforcing behavior rather than occupying a puppy’s mouth. Spring wrist straps extend from 16 to 25 centimeters, though the listing’s wording leaves some uncertainty about how they fit in use. It also gives no details on click volume or durability, which makes it harder to judge for noise-sensitive puppies or heavy daily practice. I’d choose it as a simple starter tool, paired with rewards and consistent timing.
Pros:- Supports reward-based training by marking desired behavior.
- Two clickers can be shared between trainers or kept in different locations.
- Different black and blue colors make the pair easy to distinguish.
- Spring wrist straps extend from 16 to 25 centimeters.
Cons:- Listing provides no durability information.
- Click sound volume is not specified, which may matter for sensitive puppies or indoor use.
- Wrist-strap description is unclear.
Best for: New puppy owners who want a basic clicker for reward-based cue training, especially when two people share training duties.
Not ideal for: Buyers who need documented sound-volume or durability details, or trainers who prefer a silent marker or treat-only method.
- Brand:HoAoOo
- Model:ch-clicker01
- Package quantity:2 clickers
- Colors:Black and blue
- Wrist strap length:16 cm (6.3 in), extends to 25 cm (9.84 in)
- Weight:1.45 oz (41 g)
- Target animals:Dogs, horses, cats, and birds
Our verdict“Pick this set for straightforward clicker practice with a puppy when you do not need detailed sound or durability specifications.”
How We Picked
I compared these supplies by the job they do in a puppy’s daily routine: rewarding behavior, managing indoor accidents, signaling potty needs, marking a cue, or supporting rest and teething. I gave more weight to practical usability, size or format, cleanup demands, and how easily an item can fit into consistent training than to claims that cannot be verified from the listed product details.
The ranking reflects usefulness across common puppy-training situations, not a claim that one item replaces the others. The chicken Pupford treats lead as the most straightforward frequent-reward pick; large pads and reusable or automated potty systems rank by the balance they offer between coverage and maintenance. Specialized products, including doorbells, a comfort toy, and teething sticks, rank lower because they address narrower needs. Since puppies vary in appetite, chewing habits, and home setup, I call out tradeoffs so buyers can choose by fit rather than assume every supply is necessary.
Factors to Consider When Choosing Best Puppy Training Supplies
Before adding supplies to your cart, match each item to a specific training task and your household routine. I would start with the tools that solve a current problem, then add specialized gear only if it makes practice or cleanup easier.
Choose rewards for repetition, not just novelty
Puppies may need many small rewards during short sessions, so a treat’s size, texture, and ease of portioning can matter more than having a large range of flavors. Soft options are often easier to break into small pieces, while richer or less familiar treats may be better reserved for distractions or especially useful behaviors. Try one new treat at a time so you can tell whether your puppy likes it and whether it agrees with their digestion. Avoid turning every training moment into a high-calorie snack by counting treats as part of the daily food allowance. For puppies with dietary sensitivities, check the ingredient list with your veterinarian instead of relying on a product name alone.
Match potty coverage to the room and routine
A pad that is too small for the puppy’s usual potty spot can create messes just beyond its edge, so measure the intended area and consider how your puppy moves before choosing a size. Larger disposable pads can offer quick cleanup, but they create ongoing waste and need replacing. Washable pads reduce single-use materials, though you will need enough clean replacements to keep the routine consistent while one is in the laundry. Turf trays can feel different underfoot from flat pads, which may help some homes create a distinct potty station but may complicate a later switch to outdoor grass. Pick one setup first and give the puppy a steady location rather than moving the target around.
Count the real maintenance cost of indoor potty systems
Convenience is not only about the moment an accident happens; it also includes emptying, washing, replacing, and storing supplies. Automated systems may reduce direct handling, but buyers should check what consumables they require and whether the unit suits the household’s available space. Reusable pads need prompt washing to limit lingering odor, while disposable pads require a reliable supply and a place to discard them. Grass-style surfaces also need cleaning and drying, so think about ventilation and where maintenance will happen. Choose the system whose upkeep you can sustain on busy days, not just the one that appears easiest at first glance.
Use signals and clickers consistently
Doorbells and clickers are communication aids, not self-teaching devices. A puppy needs a clear association between ringing the bell and going outside, or between the click and receiving a reward. Keep the signal simple and use the same response each time; changing the routine can make the cue less clear. Bells need to hang at a height the puppy can reach without becoming a chew toy, while a clicker should be easy to access before the behavior ends. If household members use different cues or respond at different times, the puppy may learn an inconsistent pattern.
Buy comfort and chew items for a specific need
A settling toy and a teething chew can support the conditions for training, but neither replaces supervised rest or suitable chew management. Consider your puppy’s size, chewing intensity, and interest in unfamiliar toys before choosing a comfort or chew product. Inspect chew items regularly and follow their use guidance, removing anything damaged or small enough to become a choking hazard. A heartbeat toy may be useful for a puppy adjusting to a new sleeping place, while teething sticks address a different need and are not a substitute for toys that can be used under supervision. Avoid buying several comfort products at once; introduce one at a time to see what your puppy actually uses.
Frequently Asked Questions
Should I start with disposable pee pads or a reusable potty surface?
Choose based on how often you can clean and what potty location you want your puppy to learn. Disposable pads are simple to replace during a demanding schedule, while washable pads and turf setups trade that convenience for repeated cleaning. If your long-term goal is outdoor pottying, keep indoor use in a fixed spot and take the puppy outside on a consistent schedule so the surface does not become the only learned cue. Avoid mixing several indoor potty surfaces at once unless you have a clear reason, since that can blur the target. Revisit the setup as your puppy gains reliable outdoor access.
Are soft treats or freeze-dried treats better for puppy training?
Neither format is best for every puppy or every lesson. Soft treats can be easy to divide and deliver quickly during frequent repetitions, while freeze-dried liver offers a different texture and may appeal to puppies who need a higher-interest reward. The best choice is one your puppy can eat promptly without losing focus and that suits their dietary needs. Use smaller portions for routine behaviors and save especially appealing rewards for harder settings, such as practicing around distractions. Introduce new foods gradually and ask your veterinarian about concerns related to age, allergies, or digestion.
Do puppy doorbells help with potty training if I already take my puppy outside on a schedule?
They can add a signal, but they do not replace scheduled trips, close supervision, or rewards for going in the right place. Teach the puppy to touch or ring the bell immediately before each planned trip, then take them out without delay. If the bell becomes a way to request play or attention, keep the response calm and make each trip a brief potty opportunity. A consistent household response matters more than choosing between bell designs. Give the puppy time to learn the association before expecting reliable signaling.
Is a clicker necessary if I already use verbal praise and treats?
No. A clicker is an optional marker that can make the timing of a reward more precise, but a short, consistent verbal marker can serve a similar role. The key is to mark the behavior at the moment it happens and follow with a reward, rather than clicking or speaking without a clear connection. Some owners prefer a clicker because its sound stays consistent across people; others find a verbal cue easier to keep available. Pick one marker and practice using it consistently before adding it to more complex lessons.
Which supplies should I buy first for a puppy coming home for the first time?
Start with a reward your puppy can eat comfortably, a potty setup suited to your home, and a plan for supervised rest and chewing. The exact supplies depend on whether outdoor trips are immediately available, how long the puppy may be left between breaks, and where the puppy will sleep. A clicker, doorbell, or automated potty system can wait until you know which training challenges are most pressing. Buy a modest amount of treats at first so you can check your puppy’s response before stocking up. Keep new items simple and introduce them one at a time.
Conclusion
For most households, I would start with Pupford Soft & Chewy Chicken Training Treats as the best overall because quick, repeatable rewards are useful across many early lessons. KISENG Extra Large Pee Pads are my best value-style pick for buyers who want broad disposable coverage, while BrilliantPad is the premium choice for households prioritizing automated indoor potty handling and willing to manage a more involved system. New puppy owners can build a straightforward kit around treats, a consistent potty surface, and a clicker or clear verbal marker rather than buying every specialty item at once. For reusable potty training, compare Caldwell’s washable pads with the Hompet grass tray based on cleaning preference and surface fit; choose KEXIAVA or Luckyiren bells if you want a signaling cue. Add the Snuggle Puppy or N-Bone teething sticks only when settling or chewing is a specific need. The best kit is the one your household can use consistently, not the one with the most pieces.
Halloween Picks
halloween
As an affiliate, we earn on qualifying purchases.
