My best overall pick among the best pumpkin dog biscuits is Wag Expedition Organic Dog Biscuits with Pumpkin & Chia Seed, which stands out for its organic positioning and distinctive ingredient pairing. For a soft treat, Bocce’s Bakery Pumpkin Spice offers a chewy alternative, while Wholesome Pride Nature’s Biscuits is a straightforward pick for shoppers who want a larger bag. The main tradeoffs are crunchy versus soft texture, ingredient preferences, and whether you want a basic biscuit or an added feature such as chicken wrapping or training-sized pieces. Read on for how all 15 options compare and which type of dog each one may suit.
Get pet supplies delivered free with Prime
- Fast, free delivery on millions of items
- Prime Video, Amazon Music and more included
- Member-only deals all year
Complete the kit
Key Takeaways
- Wag Expedition earns the overall lead for combining pumpkin with chia and an organic, human-grade ingredient focus, rather than relying on flavor alone.
- Texture is a major dividing line: Bocce’s Bakery and Blue Dog Bakery Softies suit dogs that prefer chewy treats, while the lineup has many more crunchy options.
- Large bags are available in more than one style: Wholesome Pride and Blue Buffalo Health Bars offer 16-ounce formats, but ingredient and recipe preferences should guide the choice.
- Some picks add a specific twist: Pawmate wraps pumpkin biscuits with chicken, while The Honest Kitchen pairs pumpkin with goat’s milk in a training-treat format.
- Special labels do not settle every dietary question: grain-free, wheat-free, and human-grade descriptions still call for checking the full ingredient list and treat size.
| pumpkin dog biscuit | Brand | Flavor | Weight | Age range |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Wag Expedition Organic Dog Bis | WAG | Pumpkin & Chia Seed | 10 oz | All life stages |
| Merrick Oven Baked Pumpkin Dog | Merrick | Pumpkin | 11 oz | — |
| Bocce’s Bakery Pumpkin Spice F | Bocce’s Bakery | Pumpkin Spice | 6 oz | All life stages |
| Portland Pet Food Pumpkin Dog | Portland Pet Food Company | Pumpkin | — | All life stages |
| Wholesome Pride Nature’s Biscu | Wholesome Pride | Pumpkin | 16 oz | — |
| Pawmate Dog Treats Chicken Wra | Pawmate | Chicken & Pumpkin Biscuit | 10.6 oz | All life stages |
| Blue Buffalo Health Bars Pumpk | Blue Buffalo | Pumpkin & Cinnamon | 16 oz | All life stages |
| The Farmer’s Dog Human-Grade C | The Farmer’s Dog | Peanut Butter & Pumpkin | 10 oz | All life stages |
| Wag More Bark Less Crunchy Dog | Cloud Star | Pumpkin | 14 oz | — |
| The Honest Kitchen Whole Grain | The Honest Kitchen | Pumpkin | 8 oz | All life stages |
| Blue Buffalo Boo Bars Pumpkin | Blue Buffalo | Pumpkin & Cinnamon | 11 oz | All life stages |
| Benefit Biscuits Dog Treats | Benefit Pet Products | Pumpkin | — | All life stages |
| Old Mother Hubbard Classic Gra | Old Mother Hubbard | Pumpkin & Carrot | — | — |
| Blue Dog Bakery Softies Pumpki | Blue Dog Bakery | Pumpkin | 10 oz | All life stages |
| Buddy Biscuits Crunchy Wheat F | Buddy Biscuits | Pumpkin | 14 oz | All life stages |
More Details on Our Top Picks
Wag Expedition Organic Dog Biscuits with Pumpkin & Chia Seed
Organic pumpkin and chia set these biscuits apart for buyers who prioritize ingredient sourcing over a long flavor menu. The product data identifies both ingredients and describes the recipe as organic, non-GMO, and human-grade, while the all-life-stages guidance suits households with dogs of different ages. Compared with Merrick Oven Baked Pumpkin Dog Treats, which emphasize a short, wheat-, corn-, and soy-free ingredient profile, Wag Expedition’s clearest distinction is its organic and chia-seed focus. The tradeoff is limited detail for portion planning: calorie content is not provided, and the listed bag size is 10 oz. I’d choose these for an ingredient-conscious household, but not if a clearly stated calorie count or several package-size choices are priorities.
Pros:- Described as organic, non-GMO, and human-grade
- Pumpkin and chia seed provide a distinctive ingredient combination
- Listed for dogs across all life stages
- Can be used as a treat, training aid, or reward
Cons:- Calorie content is not provided for portion planning
- Only the 10 oz size is listed
- The listed flavor is limited to pumpkin and chia seed
Best for: Dog owners who prioritize organic, non-GMO ingredients and want one pumpkin biscuit described as suitable for every life stage.
Not ideal for: Owners managing treat calories closely or seeking multiple bag sizes, since calorie information and alternate sizes are not listed.
- Brand:WAG
- Flavor:Pumpkin & Chia Seed
- Ingredients:Pumpkin, chia seeds
- Diet description:Organic, non-GMO; listed as veterinary diet
- Age range:All life stages
- Breed recommendation:All breed sizes
- Container:Bag
- Weight:10 oz
Our verdict“Choose Wag Expedition if organic sourcing and chia seed matter more to you than calorie details or package-size flexibility.”
Merrick Oven Baked Pumpkin Dog Treats
Real pumpkin and a limited-ingredient recipe make Merrick a practical pick for owners trying to avoid several common ingredients. The listed formula is free of wheat, corn, and soy, with no artificial colors, flavors, or preservatives. Its oven-baked wafer form also gives it a crunchier profile than the soft Bocce’s Bakery Pumpkin Spice treats, so the choice comes down partly to texture. Merrick’s broad breed-size recommendation and 11 oz bag suit everyday treat routines, though the product information does not give a calorie count or identify the full ingredient list beyond noting six ingredients. I’d favor it over Wag Expedition when avoiding wheat, corn, and soy is the main filter; I’d skip it for dogs that struggle with firm, crunchy treats or need a softer training reward.
Pros:- Made with real pumpkin and described as limited-ingredient
- Free of wheat, corn, and soy
- No artificial colors, flavors, or preservatives listed
- Recommended for all breed sizes
Cons:- Crunchy wafer texture may not suit dogs that need softer treats
- Calorie content is not provided
- The listed flavor is pumpkin only
Best for: Owners seeking a crunchy pumpkin treat without wheat, corn, soy, or artificial colors, flavors, and preservatives.
Not ideal for: Dogs with difficulty chewing firm treats, or buyers who need calorie information and a fully itemized ingredient list before choosing.
- Brand:Merrick
- Flavor:Pumpkin
- Item form:Wafer
- Weight:11 oz
- Ingredient profile:Limited ingredient; six ingredients stated
- Excluded ingredients:Wheat, corn, and soy
- Artificial additives:No artificial colors, flavors, or preservatives
- Breed recommendation:All breed sizes
Our verdict“Pick Merrick for a crunchy pumpkin biscuit with several common ingredients excluded, but choose Bocce’s Bakery if your dog needs a soft texture.”
Bocce’s Bakery Pumpkin Spice Flavor Soft & Chewy Dog Treats
Soft, chewy pieces are Bocce’s Bakery’s main advantage for dogs that find biscuits like Wholesome Pride Nature’s Biscuits too crunchy. The listed recipe includes pumpkin, peanut butter, oats, flaxseed, and cinnamon, and the product data gives a clear 13 calories per treat—useful when fitting rewards into a feeding routine. It is described as wheat-free, grain-free, and suitable for all life stages, though the ingredient list includes oat flour and rolled oats, so buyers should check the full label if they avoid particular grains. The 6 oz bag is smaller than the 10 oz Wag Expedition or 11 oz Merrick options, which may mean more frequent restocking. I’d choose it for softer rewards and portion awareness, not for households looking for a larger bag or a simpler ingredient panel.
Pros:- Soft and chewy texture offers an alternative to crunchy biscuits
- Provides a stated 13 calories per treat
- Listed as wheat-free and suitable for all life stages
- Includes pumpkin, peanut butter, and flaxseed
Cons:- The 6 oz bag is smaller than the Merrick and Wag Expedition options
- The ingredient list includes oat flour and rolled oats despite the grain-free description
- Pumpkin spice is the listed flavor, limiting flavor choice
Best for: Owners of puppies, senior dogs, or dogs that prefer softer treats, especially those who want a stated calorie count per piece.
Not ideal for: Buyers who want a larger bag, a very short ingredient list, or to avoid oats as well as wheat.
- Brand:Bocce’s Bakery
- Flavor:Pumpkin Spice
- Item form:Soft and chewy chunk
- Weight:6 oz
- Calories:13 calories per treat
- Listed ingredients:Oat flour, pumpkin, rolled oats, peanut butter, coconut glycerin, molasses, flaxseed, vegetable oil, cinnamon, citric acid
- Diet description:Limited ingredient; wheat-free and described as grain-free
- Age range:All life stages
Our verdict“Choose Bocce’s Bakery for soft, portion-aware pumpkin rewards, but check its oat ingredients and smaller bag size against your needs.”
Portland Pet Food Pumpkin Dog Treats
Resealable packaging and a low-calorie description make this three-pack a useful fit for owners who keep treats handy for training or regular rewards. Its ingredient list names pumpkin puree, garbanzo bean flour, peanut butter, molasses, and cinnamon, and the treats are described as human-grade, grain-free, and gluten-free. Compared with Bocce’s Bakery Pumpkin Spice, Portland Pet Food’s listing puts more emphasis on a resealable multi-pack and everyday portability, while Bocce’s provides a specific calorie figure per treat. Portland’s product data does not state the actual calories, so I wouldn’t choose it when precise calorie tracking matters. Its crunchy texture may also be less suitable for dogs needing soft rewards. This pick makes sense for buyers who value convenient storage and a pumpkin-centered recipe, with the caveat that portion details are limited.
Pros:- Resealable bag packaging is suited to storing treats between sessions
- Made with pumpkin puree and a short listed ingredient set
- Described as grain-free and gluten-free
- Listed for all life stages and breed sizes
Cons:- The product data does not provide a calorie count
- Crunchy texture may not suit dogs that need soft treats
- Cinnamon is included, which may not fit every dog’s preferences or sensitivities
Best for: Dog owners who want resealable pumpkin treats for frequent training or everyday rewards and prefer a grain-free, gluten-free recipe.
Not ideal for: Owners who need a stated calorie count or dogs that do better with soft, easy-to-chew treats.
- Brand:Portland Pet Food Company
- Flavor:Pumpkin
- Listed ingredients:Pumpkin puree, garbanzo bean flour, peanut butter, molasses, cinnamon
- Diet description:Grain-free and gluten-free
- Age range:All life stages
- Breed recommendation:All breed sizes
- Container:Resealable bag
- Pack:3-pack
Our verdict“Choose Portland Pet Food for resealable, grain-free pumpkin rewards, but opt for Bocce’s Bakery if a stated per-treat calorie count or softer texture matters more.”
Wholesome Pride Nature’s Biscuits Dog Treats, Pumpkin
Three listed ingredients—whole wheat flour, pumpkin, and molasses—give Wholesome Pride a straightforward recipe compared with the longer ingredient panels of Bocce’s Bakery Pumpkin Spice and Portland Pet Food Pumpkin Treats. Its 16 oz bag is also larger than those options, making it a natural fit for households that want a familiar crunchy biscuit on hand. The bone shape and chewable form suit dogs that enjoy a firm texture, while the product description connects the crunch with teeth-cleaning support. That texture is also the main limitation: it is a weaker match for dogs that need soft treats, where Bocce’s has the advantage. The recipe includes whole wheat, so it is not a fit for wheat-avoidant households. I’d pick it for a simple pumpkin biscuit, not for grain-free feeding or texture-sensitive dogs.
Pros:- Lists just whole wheat flour, pumpkin, and molasses
- 16 oz bag offers more product than the 6 oz Bocce’s Bakery option
- Bone-shaped crunchy biscuits suit dogs that prefer a firm chew
- Made in the USA and listed for all breeds and life stages
Cons:- Contains whole wheat, so it does not suit wheat-avoidant diets
- Crunchy texture may be difficult for dogs that need softer treats
- Pumpkin is the only listed flavor
Best for: Households that want a larger bag of crunchy pumpkin biscuits with a short, clearly listed ingredient set.
Not ideal for: Owners avoiding wheat, or dogs that need soft treats rather than firm, chewable biscuits.
- Brand:Wholesome Pride
- Flavor:Pumpkin
- Weight:16 oz
- Ingredients:Whole wheat flour, pumpkin, molasses
- Shape:Bone-shaped
- Item form:Chewable
- Made in:USA
- Suitable for:All breeds and all life stages
Our verdict“Choose Wholesome Pride for a larger bag of simple, crunchy pumpkin biscuits if your dog eats wheat and handles firm treats comfortably.”
Pawmate Dog Treats Chicken Wrapped Pumpkin Biscuits 10.6 oz
Chicken wrapped around a pumpkin biscuit gives this treat a different appeal from the plain pumpkin crunch of Wag More Bark Less Crunchy Dog Treats. That combination may suit dogs who need a more enticing reward, while the stick form offers a longer chew than a small training biscuit. The listing describes it as grain-free and rawhide-free and notes uses including dental care and training. Its 10.6-ounce bag sits between The Farmer’s Dog Human-Grade Crunchy Biscuits at 10 ounces and Blue Buffalo Health Bars at 16 ounces, but the chicken coating—not a larger biscuit quantity—is the main point of difference. I’d skip it for dogs that prefer soft treats or have a sensitivity to chicken or pumpkin; the ingredient details provided are limited, so check the full label before buying.
Pros:- Chicken-wrapped biscuit offers a more enticing flavor combination than plain pumpkin treats
- Grain-free and rawhide-free according to the product data
- Stick form can provide more chewing time than small wafer-style biscuits
Cons:- May not suit dogs that prefer soft treats or have difficulty chewing
- Chicken adds another potential sensitivity alongside pumpkin
- Ingredient information provided is limited beyond pumpkin
Best for: Owners of small or medium dogs who want a grain-free, rawhide-free chew with pumpkin and chicken for occasional rewards.
Not ideal for: Dogs that need soft, easily broken training treats, or dogs with known sensitivity to chicken or pumpkin.
- Brand:Pawmate
- Flavor:Chicken & Pumpkin Biscuit
- Form:Stick
- Weight:10.6 oz
- Age range:All life stages
- Container:Bag
- Allergen information:Grain-free, rawhide-free
Our verdict“Choose Pawmate if your dog prefers a chicken-coated chew over a plain pumpkin biscuit, but pass if you need a soft or clearly detailed single-ingredient treat.”
Blue Buffalo Health Bars Pumpkin & Cinnamon Dog Biscuits, 16 oz
For buyers who want a familiar baked biscuit in a larger bag, Blue Buffalo Health Bars offer pumpkin and cinnamon in a crunchy wafer form. The 16-ounce size is more generous than The Honest Kitchen Whole Grain Goat’s Milk N’ Cookies at 8 ounces, making it a better fit for households that give biscuits regularly. The listing also specifies corn-free, gluten-free and soy-free, plus whole grains, omega-3 fatty acids and antioxidants. That makes this a broader everyday biscuit choice than Wag More Bark Less, whose appeal is its simpler pumpkin-and-flaxseed positioning. The tradeoff is that these are crunchy, not soft or especially compact training rewards, and the cinnamon flavor may not appeal to every dog. I’d also compare the full ingredient label with your dog’s dietary needs rather than relying on the health claims alone.
Pros:- 16-ounce bag provides more product than several smaller options in this lineup
- Pumpkin and cinnamon offer a distinct flavor from plain pumpkin biscuits
- Listed as corn-free, gluten-free and soy-free
- Oven-baked wafer form provides a firm crunch
Cons:- Contains whole grains, so it is not a grain-free choice
- Crunchy wafer texture may not suit dogs needing softer treats
- Pumpkin and cinnamon may offer less flavor flexibility than a plain pumpkin biscuit
Best for: Multi-dog households or frequent treat-givers seeking a larger bag of crunchy pumpkin biscuits with listed grain exclusions.
Not ideal for: Owners seeking a grain-free recipe, soft treats, or small rewards that can be quickly broken into training portions.
- Brand:Blue Buffalo
- Flavor:Pumpkin & Cinnamon
- Weight:16 oz
- Form:Wafer
- Age range:All life stages
- Breed recommendation:All breed sizes
- Allergen information:Corn-free, gluten-free, soy-free
Our verdict“Pick Blue Buffalo Health Bars for a larger supply of crunchy, pumpkin-and-cinnamon biscuits, but choose another option if your dog needs grain-free or soft treats.”
The Farmer’s Dog Human-Grade Crunchy Dog Biscuits, Peanut Butter & Pumpkin
Nine calories per biscuit is the clearest practical distinction here: it gives portion-conscious owners a defined serving detail that the other products in this group do not provide. The peanut butter-and-pumpkin pairing also brings more flavor variety than Wag More Bark Less Crunchy Dog Treats, which centers on pumpkin. The Farmer’s Dog describes these as human-grade, made in the USA, and free from artificial ingredients and fillers. At 10 ounces, the pouch is smaller than Blue Buffalo Health Bars’ 16-ounce bag, so it is less suited to a home that goes through biscuits quickly. The listing calls the treats crunchy, though the form field says chewable; owners who need a specific texture or ingredient assurance should check the package details. This is a considered pick for measured treating, not the biggest or simplest pumpkin-only option.
Pros:- Lists 9 calories per biscuit for more deliberate portioning
- Human-grade ingredient claim and made in the USA
- Peanut butter adds flavor variety alongside pumpkin
- Suitable for all ages and breed sizes according to the listing
Cons:- Peanut butter makes it unsuitable for dogs with related sensitivities
- 10-ounce pouch is smaller than Blue Buffalo Health Bars’ 16-ounce bag
- The crunchy description and chewable form listing leave texture less clearly defined
Best for: Owners managing treat portions who want a peanut butter-and-pumpkin biscuit with a stated calorie count per piece.
Not ideal for: Households needing a larger bag, dogs with peanut sensitivities, or buyers looking for a plain pumpkin recipe.
- Brand:The Farmer’s Dog
- Flavor:Peanut Butter & Pumpkin
- Weight:10 oz
- Calories:9 calories per biscuit
- Form:Chewable; described as crunchy
- Age range:All life stages
- Made in:USA
- Container:Pouch
Our verdict“Choose The Farmer’s Dog biscuits if a stated per-piece calorie count and peanut butter-pumpkin flavor matter more than a larger bag or a pumpkin-only recipe.”
Wag More Bark Less Crunchy Dog Treats, Pumpkin, 14 oz Box
Plain pumpkin flavor with flaxseed makes Wag More Bark Less a straightforward choice for buyers who would rather avoid cinnamon or peanut butter. It is described as oven-baked, low-calorie and free from artificial colors and flavors, with a 14-ounce package that holds more than The Honest Kitchen’s 8-ounce bag but less than Blue Buffalo Health Bars’ 16-ounce option. The grain-free and gluten-free positioning also sets it apart from Health Bars, which contains whole grains. That simplicity is useful when you want a pumpkin-focused biscuit, but it also means less flavor variety than Pawmate’s chicken-wrapped pumpkin sticks. These treats are crunchy, so they are a poor match for dogs that need a softer texture or for training sessions where a biscuit must be easy to divide. The product data doesn’t specify calories per treat, so portion size may take some judgment.
Pros:- Pumpkin and flaxseed keep the flavor profile focused
- Listed as grain-free and gluten-free
- No artificial colors or flavors according to the product data
- 14-ounce package is larger than The Honest Kitchen’s 8-ounce bag
Cons:- Crunchy texture may not work for dogs that prefer soft treats
- Plain pumpkin offers less flavor variety than Pawmate’s chicken-wrapped option
- Calories per biscuit are not specified in the supplied product data
Best for: Owners seeking a pumpkin-forward, grain-free crunchy biscuit without added cinnamon or peanut butter flavors.
Not ideal for: Dogs that need soft or easily crumbled rewards, or owners who require a stated calorie count for each treat.
- Brand:Cloud Star
- Flavor:Pumpkin
- Weight:14 oz
- Form:Crunchy
- Container:Bag
- Nutrient claim:Low calorie
- Allergen information:Gluten-free
- Breed recommendation:All breed sizes
Our verdict“Choose Wag More Bark Less for a simple, grain-free pumpkin crunch, but look elsewhere for soft texture or clearly stated calories per treat.”
Goat’s milk and pumpkin give these biscuits a more specific digestive-health angle than Wag More Bark Less, which emphasizes a simpler pumpkin-and-flaxseed recipe. The Honest Kitchen also lists probiotic support, while its slow-baked crunchy discs are intended for training and everyday snacks. That disc shape may be easier to portion than Pawmate’s chicken-wrapped sticks, though neither option is described as soft. The 8-ounce bag is the smallest package in this five-product group, so it is a more sensible fit for occasional rewards than for a large dog that receives treats throughout the day. Its whole-grain recipe and goat’s milk also make it less suitable for dogs that need grain-free treats or avoid dairy ingredients. I’d choose it for the ingredient pairing and training focus, not for a large-volume supply.
Pros:- Goat’s milk and pumpkin provide a distinct ingredient pairing
- Product data lists digestive and probiotic support
- Disc form suits training and routine snacking
- Suitable for all life stages and breed sizes
Cons:- 8-ounce bag is smaller than the other listed packages in this group
- Goat’s milk may not suit dogs avoiding dairy ingredients
- Crunchy whole-grain biscuits are not a grain-free or soft-treat option
Best for: Owners looking for a crunchy pumpkin training biscuit with goat’s milk and listed probiotic support.
Not ideal for: Dogs with dairy sensitivities or owners who need grain-free treats and larger, longer-lasting packaging.
- Brand:The Honest Kitchen
- Flavor:Pumpkin
- Weight:8 oz
- Form:Discs
- Main ingredients:Goat’s milk, pumpkin
- Specific use:Training
- Age range:All life stages
- Allergen information:Soy-free
Our verdict“Choose The Honest Kitchen for a smaller training biscuit with goat’s milk and pumpkin, but skip it if your dog needs grain-free or dairy-free treats.”
Blue Buffalo Boo Bars Pumpkin & Cinnamon Dog Biscuits, 11 oz
Pumpkin and cinnamon give these oven-baked biscuits a seasonal angle, while their crunchy texture makes them more like an everyday reward than a soft, occasional snack. I’d pick Boo Bars for households that want a Halloween-themed treat that still suits dogs of all sizes and life stages. They’re free from corn, wheat, soy, and chicken by-products, a useful ingredient distinction compared with Buddy Biscuits Crunchy Wheat Free, which is pumpkin-forward without the cinnamon note. The tradeoff is that Boo Bars are marked for intermittent or supplemental feeding, so they aren’t a meal substitute. Their artificial shapes may also be less appealing to buyers who prefer treats with a plain, functional look. For year-round pumpkin biscuits without a holiday feel, Benefit Biscuits is the more straightforward choice.
Pros:- Combines pumpkin with cinnamon for a seasonal flavor distinction
- Crunchy oven-baked texture works for occasional rewards
- Free from corn, wheat, soy, and chicken by-products
- Listed for all life stages and breed sizes
Cons:- Intended for intermittent or supplemental feeding, not as a complete food
- Artificial shapes may not suit buyers who prefer simple-looking treats
- Cinnamon flavor may be less appealing to dogs that prefer plain pumpkin
Best for: Dog owners looking for a crunchy pumpkin-and-cinnamon treat for Halloween or occasional rewards across dogs of different sizes and ages
Not ideal for: Buyers seeking a plain, year-round pumpkin biscuit or a soft treat for dogs that struggle with crunch
- Brand:Blue Buffalo
- Flavor:Pumpkin & Cinnamon
- Weight:11 oz
- Form:Dry biscuit
- Container:Bag
- Age range:All life stages
- Diet type:Plant-based
- Allergen information:Corn-free, soy-free, wheat-free
Our verdict“Choose Boo Bars for a seasonal, crunchy pumpkin-and-cinnamon reward, not as a soft or everyday staple.”
Benefit Biscuits Dog Treats, Pumpkin, 1lb Bag
Real pumpkin and its natural fiber are the main reasons to choose Benefit Biscuits: the product is specifically positioned for digestive support, rather than leaning on a seasonal flavor or shape. The one-pound bag also gives frequent treat-givers more supply than Blue Buffalo Boo Bars’ 11-ounce bag. Its vegan, wheat-free, and non-GMO claims may appeal to buyers looking for a plant-based biscuit, though the supplied details name pumpkin as an ingredient without giving a full ingredient list. That leaves less information for shoppers checking several sensitivities. Unlike Blue Dog Bakery Softies, Benefit Biscuits are oven-baked and crunchy, so they’re a better fit for dogs that prefer a firm biscuit than for dogs needing an easy-chew treat. The single pumpkin flavor keeps the choice simple but limits variety.
Pros:- Real pumpkin provides natural fiber and is linked to digestive support in the product details
- One-pound bag offers more quantity than the 10- and 11-ounce options in this group
- Listed as vegan, wheat-free, and non-GMO
- Crunchy, oven-baked biscuit can serve as a training reward or everyday snack
Cons:- Product details give limited ingredient information beyond pumpkin
- Crunchy texture may not suit dogs that need softer treats
- Only pumpkin flavor is listed, limiting variety
Best for: Owners who want a larger-bag, vegan pumpkin biscuit with a stated digestive-support purpose for routine snacking or training
Not ideal for: Caregivers who need a soft-chew treat or shoppers who require a detailed ingredient and allergen list before buying
- Brand:Benefit Pet Products
- Flavor:Pumpkin
- Bag size:1 lb
- Form:Oven-baked biscuit
- Diet type:Vegan
- Dietary features:Wheat-free, non-GMO
- Stated benefit:Digestive support with natural fiber
- Age range:All life stages
Our verdict“Pick Benefit Biscuits if digestive-focused positioning and a larger bag matter more than flavor variety or a soft texture.”
Old Mother Hubbard Classic Grain Free Pick of the Patch Dog Biscuits, Pumpkin and Carrot Flavor, Mini Size, 16 oz Bag
Mini biscuit size is the defining advantage here: it makes these treats easier to portion during repeated training rewards than the larger-format pumpkin snacks in this roundup. Pumpkin and carrot bring a two-ingredient flavor pairing, while the 16-ounce bag offers more listed quantity than Blue Buffalo Boo Bars or Blue Dog Bakery Softies. The recipe is described as grain-free and made without artificial preservatives or meat by-products, with chickpeas among the ingredients. That may suit buyers avoiding grains, but “grain-free” alone does not establish that a treat fits a dog’s specific allergy or veterinary diet needs. Compared with Benefit Biscuits, which emphasizes digestive support, Pick of the Patch stands out more for small portions and training use. Skip it if your dog needs a soft chew or if mini pieces are inconvenient for a large dog.
Pros:- Mini size allows smaller portions for frequent training rewards
- Pumpkin and carrot offer more flavor variation than plain-pumpkin options
- 16-ounce bag provides more listed quantity than several smaller bags in this group
- Described as grain-free and made without artificial preservatives or meat by-products
Cons:- Mini pieces may be too small or less satisfying as a standalone treat for some large dogs
- Crunchy texture may not work for dogs that need soft treats
- Grain-free labeling does not confirm suitability for an individual dog’s sensitivities
Best for: Trainers and owners of small dogs who want small, crunchy pumpkin-and-carrot rewards in a larger bag
Not ideal for: Owners seeking soft treats, large biscuits for bigger dogs, or a product matched to a veterinary diet without checking with their veterinarian
- Brand:Old Mother Hubbard
- Flavor:Pumpkin & Carrot
- Bag size:16 oz
- Size:Mini
- Form:Oven-baked biscuit treat
- Diet type:Grain-free
- Allergen information:Soy-free, wheat-free
- Breed recommendation:All breed sizes
Our verdict“Choose Pick of the Patch for frequent, small training rewards with pumpkin and carrot, provided your dog is comfortable with crunchy treats.”
Blue Dog Bakery Softies Pumpkin Chewy Dog Treats, Medium, 10 oz
Soft, chewy texture separates these pumpkin treats from the crunchy biscuits that dominate this lineup. That makes Blue Dog Bakery Softies a more sensible pick for dogs that find biscuits difficult to chew, while still offering a pumpkin-based reward for dogs of all ages. The product is described as free from artificial colors, flavors, and preservatives, and as made in the USA with ingredients from American farms. Compared with Buddy Biscuits Crunchy Wheat Free, Softies give up the crisp bite in favor of easier chewing; compared with the grain-free Old Mother Hubbard minis, they’re less suited to owners who want small, crunchy training pieces. The 10-ounce bag is also smaller than the 14- and 16-ounce options here, and the listing gives little detail about the full ingredient composition.
Pros:- Soft-baked, chewy form offers an alternative to crunchy pumpkin biscuits
- Made with pumpkin and described as suitable for all life stages
- Free from artificial colors, flavors, and preservatives
- Made in the USA with ingredients from American farms, according to the product details
Cons:- 10-ounce bag is smaller than several crunchy options in this roundup
- Limited ingredient detail makes dietary screening harder
- Only pumpkin flavor is listed
Best for: Owners of dogs that prefer or need a softer chew and want a pumpkin treat for dogs of different ages
Not ideal for: Buyers seeking a crunchy biscuit, a larger bag, or detailed ingredient information for careful dietary screening
- Brand:Blue Dog Bakery
- Flavor:Pumpkin
- Weight:10 oz
- Form:Soft-baked chunk
- Shape:Round
- Age range:All life stages
- Nutrient claim:High fiber
- Product claims:No artificial colors, flavors, or preservatives
Our verdict“Choose Blue Dog Bakery Softies when chewability matters more than a crunchy texture or a larger bag.”
Buddy Biscuits Crunchy Wheat Free Dog Treats, Pumpkin, 14 oz Box
Wheat-free pumpkin crunch is the clearest reason to choose Buddy Biscuits: the listing describes simple, natural ingredients and baking in the USA, without adding a digestive-support or soft-chew claim. Its 14-ounce box sits between Blue Dog Bakery Softies’ 10-ounce bag and Old Mother Hubbard’s 16-ounce bag, making it a middle-ground option for buyers who want a crunchy treat in a moderate package size. Compared with Blue Buffalo Boo Bars, Buddy Biscuits keeps the flavor focused on pumpkin rather than pumpkin and cinnamon. The crunchy texture, however, is a real limitation for dogs with dental issues or a preference for soft rewards. The product information also notes artificial shapes, which may not appeal to shoppers seeking a more natural-looking biscuit.
Pros:- Wheat-free recipe is a useful distinction for buyers avoiding wheat
- Pumpkin flavor keeps the treat focused and straightforward
- 14-ounce box offers a middle-sized quantity among the listed options
- Baked in the USA and listed for dogs of all ages and sizes
Cons:- Crunchy texture may be difficult for dogs with dental or chewing issues
- Only pumpkin flavor is listed
- Artificial shapes may not suit buyers who prefer plain-looking treats
Best for: Owners who want a USA-baked, wheat-free pumpkin biscuit for dogs that enjoy crunchy treats
Not ideal for: Caregivers of dogs with dental or chewing difficulties, or buyers looking for a soft treat or a more varied flavor
- Brand:Buddy Biscuits
- Flavor:Pumpkin
- Weight:14 oz
- Form:Crunchy treat
- Container:Box
- Age range:All life stages
- Breed recommendation:All breed sizes
- Made in:USA
Our verdict“Choose Buddy Biscuits for a straightforward, wheat-free pumpkin crunch if your dog can comfortably chew firm treats.”
How We Picked
I compared these 15 treats on the qualities that change a buyer’s choice: the role of pumpkin in the recipe, texture, ingredient positioning, package format, and any added feature that sets a biscuit apart. A clear match to a common need—such as a soft bite, training-sized pieces, a distinctive recipe, or a larger bag—counted more than broad claims that did not explain the treat’s practical use.
The ranking puts the most versatile, clearly differentiated choices first, then sorts the rest by how well each serves a narrower preference. That means a specialized option can be a better fit for one dog without outranking a more broadly useful biscuit. I also treated labels such as grain-free and human-grade as selection cues, not proof that a treat suits every dog; buyers still need to review ingredients and feeding guidance.
Factors to Consider When Choosing Best Pumpkin Dog Biscuits
Choosing a pumpkin biscuit involves more than picking the most appealing flavor name. I would start with the dog’s eating style and dietary needs, then weigh recipe details against package size and the purpose of the treat.
Match Texture to Your Dog
Crunchy biscuits and soft treats serve different preferences, even when both feature pumpkin. A dog that likes to chew may accept a firm biscuit, while a dog that avoids hard treats may do better with a chewy option. Do not assume that a soft texture makes a treat suitable for every dog with dental or chewing concerns; piece size and your dog’s individual needs still matter. For multi-dog households, texture preference can vary enough that a single large bag may go uneaten. If you are unsure, begin with a smaller package when available before committing to a pantry-sized supply.
Read the Full Ingredient List
Pumpkin in a product name does not tell you how much pumpkin the recipe contains or what else is included. Check the complete ingredient list for proteins, grains, flavorings, and other components that matter to your dog’s diet. Terms such as organic, grain-free, wheat-free, and human-grade describe particular product attributes; they do not automatically mean a biscuit is right for a dog with an allergy or sensitivity. If your dog follows a restricted diet, compare the label with the ingredients your veterinarian has advised you to avoid. A short ingredient list can be easier to review, but it is not a substitute for checking each ingredient.
Choose Treat Size for the Job
A biscuit meant for occasional rewarding may not be the best fit for frequent training. Smaller pieces can make repeated rewards easier to portion, while a larger biscuit may work better as an occasional snack for a dog that can manage its size. Mini treats are not automatically appropriate for every dog, so check the piece dimensions and supervise chewing. If a biscuit breaks cleanly, dividing it may help you manage portions, but brittle treats can crumble in a pocket or bag. Choose based on how you plan to use the treat, not just the package’s serving language.
Treat Bag Size as a Freshness Decision
A larger bag can suit a household that gives treats regularly, but it also means more time for the biscuits to sit after opening. Package weight alone does not show how many individual treats you will get, since biscuit size and density vary. Check storage directions and whether the packaging can be resealed; transfer treats to an airtight container if needed to preserve texture. For a dog trying a new flavor or texture, a smaller package limits the chance of waste if the treat is rejected. Buy a larger format only when you already know the dog will eat it at a sensible pace.
Separate Dietary Labels From Dietary Fit
Grain-free or wheat-free wording can help narrow a search, but it does not make a treat universally safer or more nutritious. A recipe may replace one ingredient with another that your dog also needs to avoid. Likewise, a human-grade claim does not answer questions about calorie content, portion size, or suitability for a particular health condition. For dogs with diagnosed allergies or a prescribed diet, verify the full formula and consult your veterinarian before introducing a new treat. For dogs without those restrictions, avoid paying extra attention to a label that does not address a real need.
Decide Whether an Added Feature Is Worth It
Some biscuits stand apart through extras such as a chicken wrap, a goat’s milk pairing, or a pumpkin-and-spice flavor profile. Those additions can make a treat more appealing to a particular dog, but they also introduce ingredients beyond pumpkin that deserve a label check. A simple biscuit may be the easier choice when you want a familiar treat with fewer recipe variables. If your dog is selective, a distinctive flavor could help, though no ingredient pairing guarantees acceptance. Let the dog’s preferences and dietary requirements decide whether the added feature earns a place in the treat jar.
Frequently Asked Questions
Which pumpkin dog biscuit is the best starting point if my dog has never tried one?
I would start with a basic recipe and a package size that limits waste, rather than choosing a treat for an extra flavor or specialty claim. Check the ingredient list first, especially if your dog has known food sensitivities. Offer a small piece and watch for whether your dog accepts the texture before making it a regular reward. If your dog follows a prescribed diet, ask your veterinarian before adding a new treat. A familiar ingredient profile is a more useful starting point than a label that sounds especially healthy.
Are crunchy pumpkin biscuits better than soft ones for dogs?
Neither texture is best for every dog; the right choice depends on chewing preference, treat size, and your dog’s ability to manage the biscuit. Crunchy treats may suit dogs that enjoy firmer bites, while soft options can be easier for dogs that reject hard textures. Do not treat either texture as a dental-care product unless the packaging and your veterinarian support that use. Supervise your dog with any new biscuit and stop if chewing seems difficult. If texture is uncertain, try a small amount before buying a larger bag.
Can pumpkin dog biscuits help with my dog’s digestion?
A pumpkin recipe is still a treat, and the product name alone does not establish how much pumpkin it contains or whether it will address a digestive problem. Ingredients and feeding amounts differ across biscuits, so read the label rather than assuming all pumpkin treats work the same way. Treats should not replace a balanced diet or veterinary guidance. If your dog has ongoing digestive symptoms, speak with a veterinarian instead of relying on biscuits to manage them. Introduce any new treat gradually and watch how your dog responds.
How do I choose a pumpkin biscuit for a dog with food sensitivities?
Start with the full ingredient list, not front-of-package terms such as grain-free, wheat-free, or human-grade. Look for every ingredient your veterinarian has advised you to avoid, including proteins and flavor additions that may be easy to overlook. A pumpkin biscuit can contain other ingredients that make it unsuitable for a dog with a specific sensitivity. If your dog is on an elimination diet or has a diagnosed allergy, confirm the recipe with your veterinarian before feeding it. Avoid introducing several new foods at once, so you can identify what your dog tolerates.
Should I buy a large bag if pumpkin biscuits are part of my dog’s daily routine?
A large package can be convenient when your dog already accepts the biscuit, but bag weight does not tell you how many treats it contains or how quickly they will be used. Check the feeding guidance and account for treats as part of your dog’s overall daily intake. Storage matters too: follow the package directions and keep the biscuits sealed to protect their texture. If your dog is new to the recipe, try a smaller package first so a poor texture match does not leave you with a surplus. For routine rewards, portion size and freshness matter more than package size alone.
Conclusion
For the best overall choice, I recommend Wag Expedition for shoppers who want an organic, human-grade positioning with pumpkin and chia in the recipe. For value in a larger bag, consider Wholesome Pride Nature’s Biscuits, while buyers seeking a premium ingredient profile may prefer The Farmer’s Dog Human-Grade Crunchy Biscuits or The Honest Kitchen’s pumpkin recipe, depending on the added ingredients they want. For beginners, start with a modest package of a straightforward biscuit and confirm that your dog likes its texture before stocking up. If your dog prefers chewy treats, look at Bocce’s Bakery or Blue Dog Bakery Softies; if you want an added chicken feature, Pawmate is the more specialized pick. My final choice would depend on your dog’s texture preference, dietary needs, and how often you plan to offer treats.
Fall Picks
fall essentials
As an affiliate, we earn on qualifying purchases.
